...
Looking for healthier crown alternatives, Thineers, or new implant options? Call or text (801) 503-0035 — Dr. Williams can help you
Dental Insurance & Membership

Dental Insurance vs. Membership: The Scary Truth About Open Enrollment

By Dr. Tyler Williams, DDS · October 31, 2026 · 5 min read

When I was a kid, around this time of year, I remember a radio ad (yeah, that’s how we enjoyed music before Spotify 🙂) for “Alien Encounters on Redwood Road.”

It was an old “haunted” two-story house just up the road at 5959 S. Redwood Road, a few blocks from our office. It was demolished in 1997 for safety reasons.

Who would have known that 25+ years later I’d set up a practice right down the road to help people avoid the scary side of the dentist?!?

Speaking of scary: it’s open enrollment season. Stacks of plans, tiny print, and a “dental benefit” that sounds amazing until you try to use it. After 16+ years in practice, here’s what I’ve learned: the scariest part of the dentist usually isn’t the dentist. It’s the fine print.

So let’s open the door and look around. Here’s an honest comparison of dental insurance and the Pinecrest Smile Club, including where insurance is the better choice.

What dental insurance does well

Insurance is built for routine care. If your employer pays part of the premium, and you mostly need cleanings, exams and the occasional tooth repair, a plan can easily pay for itself. It also lets you see many different dentists.

Where dental insurance gets scary

Five monsters tend to hide in individual plans:

  • The annual maximum. Most individual plans stop paying after $1,000 to $2,500 a year. A single implant can use that up quickly.
  • The waiting period. Many plans wait 6 to 12 months before paying for major work.
  • The two-visit limit. Insurance generally covers 2 office visits a year, then nothing.
  • The deductible. Often $50 to $100 before the plan pays.
  • The exclusions. Whitening, Veneers, Sedation, Saliva Testing and Full Mouth Implants are commonly excluded or limited.

None of this makes insurance a scam. It just means it was designed for maintenance, not for planned, bigger treatment.

What the Pinecrest Smile Club is

Smile Club is our in-house membership. There’s no insurance company, no claims and no annual maximum. Benefits start right away.

Gold: $624 a year ($62 a month)

  • 3 free non-emergency or checkup evaluations a year. Insurance covers 2, then nothing.
  • 2 free cleanings a year, with the 3rd and beyond heavily discounted.
  • $0 emergency visits, with treatment at a discounted member rate.
  • $0 deductible and no annual maximum.
  • Unlimited needed Digital X-Rays.
  • Free or dramatically reduced price on laughing gas and Comfort Care Sedation.
  • Free extended rolling warranty on materials for any major dental work or Implants.
  • Member pricing on Implants, Biomimetic Dentistry and Thin-neers.

Platinum: $1,079 a year ($107 a month)

  • 4 full preventive cleanings per year, plus up to 8 monthly touch-up polish and varnish visits. That's one cleaning or touch-up every month.
  • Unlimited office visits and $0 emergency visits every year, with treatment at a discounted member rate.
  • Unlimited needed Digital X-Rays.
  • Free, unlimited laughing gas or Comfort Care Sedation.
  • Free Whitening, free mineralization and custom trays. Dental insurance rarely covers these.
  • Free extended rolling warranty on materials for any major dental work or Implants.
  • Everything in Gold, including the member pricing below.

What members save (Gold and Platinum)

  • Implants: save $631 per Implant. The more Implants you need, the more the savings compound.
  • Bio overlay (a stronger and more cost-effective alternative to the old-fashioned root canal and crown): save $707 each. Plus, you’re more likely to save an additional $1,000 to $2,000 on a root canal that’s probably avoidable.
  • Thin-neers and Veneers: insurance rarely covers them, and when a plan does, it’s often 50% after a 9-month wait, counting against your annual cap.

Side by side

What you get AARP members 50+: AARP/Delta PPO (Protect Plus) Non-Medicare: typical individual plan (Utah avg) Pinecrest Smile Club Gold Pinecrest Smile Club Platinum
Monthly cost, 1 person $74 $54 $62 $107
Annual cap on benefits $2,000, then $0 $1,000–$2,500, then $0 None None
Deductible $40 (waived for cleanings, exams and x-rays) $50–$100 $0 $0
Free non-emergency or checkup evaluations 2, then no coverage 2, then no coverage 3 + savings on more Unlimited!
Preventive cleanings and touch-ups per year Typically 2 Typically 2 2 free, with the 3rd and beyond heavily discounted 12: 4 full cleanings plus up to 8 touch-up polish and varnish visits
Emergency or last-minute needs Count toward your 2 visits and your cap Count toward your 2 visits and your cap $0 emergency visit, with treatment at a discounted member rate $0 emergency visits, unlimited, with treatment at a discounted member rate
Waiting period for major work 9 months Often 6–12 months None None
Laughing gas and Comfort Care Sedation Often not covered Often not covered Free or dramatically reduced price Free and unlimited
Whitening, mineralization and custom trays Not covered Not covered Big Savings Free
Implants 50% after a 9-month wait, within the $2,000 cap Often excluded or limited Save $631 per Implant, and more with each additional one Save $631 per Implant, and more with each additional one
Bio overlay (alternative to a root canal and crown) Limited by your annual cap Limited by your annual cap Save $707 each, plus a possible $1,000–$2,000 root canal avoided Save $707 each, plus a possible $1,000–$2,000 root canal avoided
Thin-neers and Veneers Veneers: 50% after a 9-month wait, within the $2,000 cap Rarely covered Member savings Member savings
Extended rolling warranty on materials (major work and Implants) Not a plan benefit Not a plan benefit Free Free
Saliva Testing, Oral Cancer Screening, Mineral Varnish $72–$286 per year $72–$286 per year Free Free

Pros and cons, straight up

Insurance

Pros: your employer may share the cost, it’s great for cleanings and small repairs, and you can choose from many dentists.

Cons: annual maximums, waiting periods, a 2-visit limit, deductibles and frequent exclusions.

Smile Club

Pros: no annual maximum, no deductible, more included visits, free or discounted sedation, a free extended rolling warranty on major work, and member savings on bigger treatment (like a bio overlay instead of a crown or root canal).

Cons: it isn’t insurance. You pay whether or not you use it, it won’t reimburse you at another dentist, and we don’t bill insurance for it. If you’re healthy and only need cleanings, a plan through work may cost you less.

Four questions to ask before you re-enroll

  1. What’s the annual maximum?
  2. How long is the waiting period for major work?
  3. Are implants, veneers and sedation covered, and at what percentage?
  4. How many visits are covered each year?

If you don’t get a straight answer in writing, that’s your answer. And I’ll never recommend treatment based on your insurance. Your teeth don’t know what plan you’re on.

Frequently asked questions

Is Smile Club insurance?

No. It’s an in-office membership plan with set member pricing.

Do you accept dental insurance?

No. Pinecrest is a fee-for-service practice, so we don’t bill insurance.

Which level fits me?

Gold fits most people who want more visits and predictable pricing on bigger care. Platinum fits those who want unlimited office and emergency visits, a cleaning or touch-up every month, free laughing gas and sedation, plus free Whitening, mineralization and custom trays.

Limited-time Halloween Treat Bag 🎃

People put off the treatment they need most because the visit feels scary. Sedation takes that off the table. If you move forward with Implants, Bio-Veneers or 3+ Overlays by October 31, 2026, your Treat Bag includes:

  • Free Oral Sedation: lie back, relax, and let the visit disappear
  • Your choice of Free Custom Teeth Whitening or a Free Custom Teeth Grinding Mouthguard

Ready to see which fits you? Compare the levels at pinecrestdds.com/membership-plan/, or call or text (801) 268-2323.

FYI: The Pinecrest Smile Club is an in-office membership plan, not insurance. Insurance figures are general estimates based on published 2026 rates, a Delta Dental AARP PPO Protect Plus quote for 1 person in ZIP 84123 (October 2026; an AARP membership is also needed) and the 2026 Utah average from DentalInsurance.com; your own plan will vary. Savings figures are estimates and vary by treatment plan. Pinecrest Dental is not affiliated with AARP or Delta Dental, and their names belong to their owners.

← All articles
🦷 Your Next Step

Get a straight answer about your smile — starting at $67.

Book the $67 Smile Health Consultation and Dr. Williams will show you exactly what your smile needs, what it costs, and whether Smile Club or your insurance makes more sense for you.

★★★★★ America's Best Dentists × 3 · AAID · AOBMD · Se Habla Español
6065 S Redwood Rd · Taylorsville, UT 84123 · Mon–Thu 8am–5pm · Fri 7:30am–1:30pm
Pinecrest Dental $67 consult · 100% money-back guarantee
📞 (801) 503-0035
Seraphinite AcceleratorOptimized by Seraphinite Accelerator
Turns on site high speed to be attractive for people and search engines.